Buttermilk Pie Problems And Solutions

It’s sad when you are craving a velvety buttermilk pie but couldn’t bake it properly. For the most part, it seems to be a basic method. However, keep in mind that a variety of things can go wrong. 

But don’t be afraid; there are methods to prevent them, as I can guarantee you.

So, what are the buttermilk pie problems?

The first problem might be buttermilk pie is looking curdled. Another one could be the pie not setting properly. Moreover, while serving, your pie might get separated. Also, you don’t want your pie to be runny as well. Agreeing with sugar input rumors and overbaking might also get you into buttermilk pie problems.

Well, that was just the things that can go wrong with your buttermilk pie. The solutions to all of these issues are waiting for you to be discovered.

What’s the use in dragging it off any longer? Let’s move on!

Buttermilk Pie: 5 Major Problems and Solutions

There are several buttermilk pie problems that arise while baking. But, nothing to worry about. All you need to avoid addressed problems to win the situation.

Source: Insanely Good Recipes

Problem 1: Buttermilk Pie Looks Curdled

Buttermilk pie is a straightforward recipe to prepare. However, the measurements and mixing procedure are a little tricky. 

You take one stride forward and one step back, and you’re done. Your buttermilk pie has curdled up. The buttermilk might be reacted at the very same time as the other ingredients. 


The only solution to this problem is to be very careful while mixing things. Also, following the recipe perfectly will help you to prevent any mess up. So, while mixing the ingredients remember these tips.

  • While whisking butter and sugar together, use a large mixing dish.
  • Make sure you stir the flour, salt and eggs separately. 
  • And while whisking the buttermilk, lime juice and vanilla essence, use another mixing bowl.

Here are some large bowls for easily mixing all your ingredients. These bowls are obviously not only for mixing so buying them can be a good investment.

Fox Run Large Mixing BowlOrder Now!
OXO Good Grips Mixing BowlOrder Now!
Bovado Glass Bowl for MixingOrder Now!
Tovolo Stainless Steel Deep Mixing BowlOrder Now!

Problem 2: Buttermilk Pie Not Setting

There are two fundamental reasons for a runny pie filling. The first one is that your pie was too. And, the other one is your stuffing may not be appropriately set and it’s sweltering.


When serving the pie, keep it moderately warm. After baking, chill the pie on the spot for three hours. A porcelain plate may take much longer to cool than a metal pie tin.

Before removing the pie from the oven, look for thick and sticky bubbles. It should be looking more so like this.

Source: The Kitchn

If you don’t see any sight like this, give it a couple more moments. 

Problem 3: Buttermilk Pie Separates

You are mixing and processing all the steps according to the buttermilk pie recipe. But, you are seeing that still, your buttermilk pie separates.

So, you might be thinking why did my buttermilk pie separate ?

One of the most common problems with Buttermilk Pie is that it doesn’t set correctly. The major one is not letting the pie chill and set ultimately. It is not providing enough time for the pie to chill and solidify. It’s possible that your Buttermilk Pie wasn’t baked properly. 


Note that, this is a creme pie. And for that after done cooking, there’s still more work to do. And by work I mean you need to give it some time to settle down.

When removing the pie from the microwave, the core should still wiggle slightly. Time management is the vital element for the buttermilk pie. To keep track of time in the kitchen I normally use ANTONKI Kitchen Timer

Another thing that might cause problems in buttermilk pie hardening is the flour ratio. So ensure that your flour ratio is perfect. If these two suggestions are done properly, your pie will always keep its form.

Even though it has been taken from the oven, it still requires care. So, give it some time to rest and chill before serving it.

Problem 4: Buttermilk Pie Looks Runny

I know you’re frustrated about your runny buttermilk pie. But there are still some options to save your buttermilk pie. We don’t want you to get embarrassed in front of your guest.

Source: A New Recipe Each Week

So, I have mentioned few solutions on how to fix runny buttermilk pie.


There are a few simple measures you can take to make your pie filling appear the way it was intended. This way, you may enjoy the same delicious taste without consuming sloppy pie soup.

Because there exists so many options, it is completely up to you to choose the best one. Some are simpler than others, but they should all work to produce your pie filling nice and solid.

Hack 1: Cornstarch 

Adding cornstarch with your pie filling will prevent it from being runny.

One teaspoon of cornstarch per cup of filling will be sufficient for your pie. In general, a 9-inch pie should contain around six cups of filling. So, you’ll need six tablespoons of cornstarch in that case.

Hack 2: The flour

This one usually has some controversies. Some people dislike adding flour to their pie filling since it might make the filling seem murky in appearance. However, it will suffice if that is all you have on hand.

For each and every quart of fruit in your pie, you’ll require two tablespoons of flour. Instead of pouring the flour in one go, the secret is to sprinkle it in.

Otherwise, it will cluster together and ruin the flavor of your filling. It’s too simple to over-flour your filling, resulting in a runny, lumpy result. So, be careful while sprinkling the flour.

However, it’s better to use tapioca flour than using regular ones. It may take a long time to hydrate but your pie filling’s remaining fluid will leave completely. 

Thoroughly mix in the tapioca flour and stir it in. Set it aside for 15 minutes or so to allow the tapioca flour to dissolve. Here are some of the best tapioca flours that I’ve used throughout my baking life.

Anthony’s Organic Tapioca FlourBuy Now
Bob’s Red Mill Finely Ground Tapioca FlourBuy Now
Arrowhead Mills Organic Tapioca FlourBuy Now

Hack 3: Drain the Juices

If your mixture is still wet, extract it from the pie. Then, combine it with a touch of salt and lemon in a mixing dish. 

Put pressure to the fruit a little to drain more juice. When you’re done mashing, strain the mixture into a strainer to allow the sweet liquid to drain.

Source: Divas Can Cook

This is a custard-based pie, so anticipate a velvety texture. But don’t get nervous. These mentioned hacks will help you to recover from this situation.

Problem 5: Buttermilk Pie’s Misconception About Less Sugar

‘Buttermilk pie less sugar’– a common rumour for the beginner bakers. Some say buttermilk pie requires less sugar. Well, some people prefer the tangy flavor. Others like to use caramel extract or it’s substitutes. But buttermilk already contains some sweetness. So, some might get confused about the measurement.


The sweetness of the buttermilk pie is well balanced by the amount of sugar in the recipe. 

Even though the pie is somewhat tart, the tastes will stand out. 1 and ½ cup white sugar will be enough for a perfect buttermilk pie.  

The most are sweet and vanilla, which are the most prevalent. Because of its apparent taste profile, this pie is especially suitable for any occasion.

Problem 6: Buttermilk Pie Overbaked

Avoid overbaking. Move to a cooling rack and cool for 30 minutes.

It’s pretty common to over baking the pie. You need to follow the exact time to avoid such mistakes. Well, don’t be upset. There’s still some hope to rescue your buttermilk pie.


For a more delicate outcome, bake these pies at 375°F. Also, baking in hot water, like a cheesecake, may avoid possible cracks.

Definitely do not overheat the pie. After baking, the pie should have a jiggly core.

Does Buttermilk Pie Need to be Refrigerated?

Before serving, the pie must cool and be refrigerated for many hours. Check if the pie has been baked properly then refrigerate it.

Cover it in a fine layer of plastic wrap and aluminum foil to refrigerate a Buttermilk Pie. Put remaining pieces in a refrigerated, sealed container divided by baking paper. 

The pie can store and in a good condition for up to 2 months in the freezer. 

How Long to Let Buttermilk Pie Cool?

Reduce oven temperature to 325°F and bake for 50-55 minutes. Then, let it cool for around 1/1.30 hours. It will set the flavor. Cover the piecrust edges by making an aluminum foil ring

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Buttermilk Pie and Chess Pie?

People usually think both are the same. But, the chess pie is an English dessert that has traditionally been a South delicacy. Although they seem to be quite similar. Buttermilk pie often has lemon zest and nutmeg in the center. Whereas chess pie usually does not contain cornmeal. Both are delicious.

How to store left-over buttermilk pie?

Extra slices may be frozen in a sealed jar covered by pieces of tin foil. After that, cover in it aluminium foil. The pie will keep in the fridge for up to 2 months. Store in the fridge or heat for 30 seconds at a time until an optimal result is attained. You can store the whole buttermilk pie in a similar process.

What does buttermilk pie taste like?

The flavor of buttermilk pie is comparable to that of creme Brule. It’s light, delicious, and velvety. This velvety texture will melt in your mouth full of flavors. Fans of the gleaming “lid” on top of creme Brule will be pleased. Because buttermilk pie has a scratchy topping as well.

Bottom Line

I hope you now understand your buttermilk pie problems. I hope this article benefited you.

I’ll end this piece with a bonus tip. Always use measuring cups to keep all ingredients consistent. This will allow you to get everything in prime condition.

Until next time!